
PropShopTrader review
Claimed by the firm
Futures, stocks and prediction-market evaluations, run on Prop Account since October 2026
- CEO
- Sean Kozak (co-founder; the firm calls him Partner)
- Headquarters
- Estonia
- Founded
- 2024
- In business
- 2 years
- Trustpilot
- 3.6(547)
Our grade
Poor
3.8 / 10 · #33 of 43
3.6
Trustpilot
547 reviews
- 5★65%
- 4★6%
- 3★1%
- 2★2%
- 1★26%
What traders say about PropShopTrader
Trustpilot · 302 reviews analyzed
Trustpilot TrustScore
547 reviews
- · Only 428 of 547 reviews are publicly listed.
- · The firm replied to 18% of negative reviews (26 of 144), on average 4.5 days later; its last reply to a negative review was on September 16, 2026.
- · Every review from September and October 2026 is 1 or 2 stars except one, most about the Legacy account shutdown.
- · 24% of recent 5-star reviews are very short, and most longer ones praise named support agents.
Recent sentiment
Trend: declining200 most recent reviews · 0% verified
2026-03: 5.4% negative, average 4.64, 56 reviews; 2026-04: 6.2% negative, average 4.75, 32 reviews; 2026-05: 17.2% negative, average 4.14, 29 reviews; 2026-06: 83.3% negative, average 1.83, 6 reviews; 2026-07: 47.1% negative, average 3.12, 17 reviews; 2026-08: 0% negative, average 5, 2 reviews; 2026-09: 92.9% negative, average 1.36, 14 reviews; 2026-10: 100% negative, average 1, 7 reviews
Most reported issue · 73% of complaints
Accounts closed or breached
Most negative reviews describe accounts ended by the firm: the September 2026 Legacy shutdown, risk-team refusals at the live transition, or MAE and hedging flags.
Most praised · 81% of positive reviews
Helpful support agents
Positive reviews almost all thank a named support agent for quick, patient help with platform setup, rule questions or coupons.
Complaint themes · 153 negative reviews
- Account closed or breached73%
Legacy accounts disabled on September 30, 2026, plus failures from MAE flags and platform errors.
- Payout denied or never paid45%
Sim payouts removed in January 2026, live transitions and signing bonuses refused after all benchmarks, and closures before any payout.
- Rule disputes41%
Traders cite repeated retroactive rule changes, the MAE per-trade rule and a hedging algorithm that flags normal trades.
- Support and slow resolution37%
Tickets about dashboard and platform mismatches stayed under review for weeks, often until the trader gave up.
- Platform and data problems24%
After the move from Rithmic to Tickblaze, traders report ghost orders, trades not closing and a dashboard out of sync with the platform.
- Fees and refunds22%
No refunds after program changes, conversion fees paid for accounts later closed, and coupons offered instead of money.
- Payout delays16%
Payout or bonus decisions held under review for a month or longer.
Praise themes · share of 4–5★ reviews
- Helpful support81%
Named agents answer quickly, including after market hours, and walk traders through new rules.
- Trading conditions and platform14%
Some traders like the structure, the low daily profit targets of early 2026 and order-flow tools.
- Price and discounts7%
Deep discounts and low entry prices are mentioned as a reason to try the firm.
- Payouts received1%
Only 2 of 146 positive reviews describe actually getting paid.
Our read of the reviews
We read all 153 one- and two-star reviews on Trustpilot (August 2025 to October 2026) and the 200 newest reviews of any rating. The newest sample looks healthy at first, 73% positive, but it is front-loaded: February to April 2026 produced 125 reviews averaging above 4 stars, most thanking a named support agent. From June the tone flips, and September and October 2026 are almost entirely one-star.
The complaints follow the firm's rule changes. In January 2026 traders lost the ability to request payouts from Gladiator sim accounts and were moved to an eight-benchmark path toward a live account. Those who reached the end report being refused the live transition and the signing bonus over data discrepancies with Tickblaze. In spring 2026 the switch from Rithmic to Tickblaze added ghost orders and dashboard mismatches. Then on September 30 the firm disabled all Legacy accounts. Our classifier puts closed or breached accounts in 73% of negative reviews and denied payouts in 45%.
Praise is narrow. Support agents get thanked by name over and over, but only 2 of 146 positive reviews describe a payout received. The firm answered 18% of negative reviews, and none after mid-September.
Method: we collected the 200 most recent Trustpilot reviews plus the most recent 153 1–2★ reviews, classified every review by theme and read the samples by hand. Shares are of the stated sample. How we analyze reviews