Skip to contentVerified prop firm discountsSee offers
PropFirmGrades

Methodology

How we grade prop firms

Every firm gets one simple grade from A to E. It answers one question: if you buy a challenge here and trade well, how likely are you to get paid without a rule you didn't see coming taking it away?

Six scores, computed from measured facts

Step 1

Every firm is scored with the same formula from the same facts. We collect each firm's Trustpilot reviews in bulk and sort every complaint by theme, then add the firm's prices, platforms and rules. Each fact is turned into a 0 to 10 score on a fixed scale, so a firm's grade only moves when its own facts change, not when we add other firms. When a firm shares data we can verify, such as payout records, our review team checks it and can adjust that firm's scores.

Complaint counts are per 100 reviews: the share of a firm's reviews that are 1–2★ (lifetime and latest, averaged) times the share of those complaints about each theme. They are scored on a log scale, so going from 1 to 5 complaints per 100 costs as much as going from 5 to 25. Small complaint samples are blended toward the typical share so a handful of reviews can't swing a grade.

Payouts25% of the grade

  • Reviews reporting a denied, cancelled or late payout, per 100 reviews (80%)0 scores 10, 30 or more scores 0
  • Share of payout mentions in recent reviews that are positive (20%)100% scores 10, 50% or less scores 0

Transparency15% of the grade

  • Reviews reporting an account or profits lost over a rule, per 100 reviews (45%)0 scores 10, 40 or more scores 0
  • Shares data with us that our review team has verified, such as payout records (20%)Yes 10, no 3
  • Publishes its own pass-rate data (15%)Yes 10, no 3
  • Profile claimed by the firm (10%)Yes 10, no 4
  • Names who runs it: CEO, founders or directors (10%)Yes 10, no 2

Rules & trading conditions20% of the grade

  • Median list price of its $100K 1-step and 2-step challenges (30%)$350 or less scores 10, $750 or more scores 0
  • Highest profit split (15%)100% scores 10, 80% scores 4
  • A static-drawdown program is available (15%)Yes 10, no 4
  • A consistency rule applies (10%)No 10, yes 4
  • News trading on funded accounts (10%)Allowed 10, restricted 5
  • A program with no time limit (10%)Yes 10, no 3
  • Challenge fee refunded (10%)Yes 10, no 5

Reputation20% of the grade

  • Trustpilot score (35%); when Trustpilot hides it, our estimate counts one point lower4.8 scores 10, 3.0 or less scores 0
  • Share of 1–2★ reviews among the latest reviews (25%)0% scores 10, 80% scores 0
  • Years in business (25%)8+ years scores 10, a new firm 2
  • Number of Trustpilot reviews (15%)10,000+ scores 10, 100 scores 2

Platforms & execution10% of the grade

  • Mainstream CFD platforms offered: MT4, MT5, cTrader, Match-Trader and others (50%)4+ scores 10, 1 scores 3
  • Reviews reporting slippage, spread or platform problems, per 100 reviews (50%)0 scores 10, 30 or more scores 0

Support10% of the grade

  • Reviews complaining about support, per 100 reviews (70%)0 scores 10, 30 or more scores 0
  • Share of positive reviews that praise support (30%)15%+ scores 10, none scores 4

From score to grade

Step 2

The weighted score out of 10 maps to a grade. A and B are firms you can buy from with normal care. From C down, read the hidden-rules page before you pay.

  • AExcellent≥ 7.5Reliable payouts, clear rules, strong track record.
  • BGood≥ 6.5Solid choice with a few rules to watch.
  • CAverage≥ 5.5Usable, but read the hidden rules before you buy.
  • DWeak≥ 4.5Frequent complaints or risky rules. Proceed with care.
  • EPoor< 4.5Serious payout or rule problems. We'd avoid it.

The Hidden Risk score

Separate from the grade

Hidden Risk measures how likely you are to lose an account or a payout to a rule rather than to the market. It runs from 0 to 10, and lower is better. It is computed from the same facts as the grade: rule-dispute reviews per 100 (40%), payout complaints per 100 (30%) and rules a trader can't avoid by picking another program (30%): a consistency rule on every program, no static-drawdown option and a ban on news trading. Rules that only some programs have, and the short news windows nearly every firm uses, are written down in advance and already count in Conditions, so they don't count twice. Each review also lists the specific rules behind it, with sources, on the firm's rules page.

  • Low · 0 – 2.4

    Few restrictions beyond drawdown; everything important is documented up front.

  • Moderate · 2.5 – 3.9

    Some easy-to-miss rules (news windows, lot caps, consistency) but clearly published.

  • High · 4.0 – 5.4

    Several rules that commonly void profits or accounts; read the terms line by line.

  • Very high · 5.5 – 10

    Broad discretionary clauses or a history of applying rules after the fact.

Red flags

Same thresholds for every firm

A red flag only appears when a firm crosses one of these fixed lines. We only flag things that cost traders money, accounts or payouts, not legal boilerplate most firms share.

The same goes for the hidden rules on each review. Standard contract terms aren't listed as risks: the right to close accounts or withhold payouts on suspected violations, “decisions are final”, changing the terms, arbitration, governing law, legal costs or non-disparagement. We list a discretionary rule only when it is a specific trading mechanic, such as a risk cap, a consistency test or an interview.

  • No trader reviews yetThe firm has no Trustpilot reviews, or fewer than 50 (the flag then reads "Too few trader reviews"). Missing evidence is not neutral: every review-based metric (payout complaints, rule disputes, Trustpilot score, support and execution) scores as unproven, and the review parts of Hidden risk count as high, so a firm can't grade well before traders have reported on it.
  • Trustpilot hides its scoreTrustpilot has removed the firm's TrustScore, which it does after finding fake reviews or other guideline breaches.
  • Many payout complaints2 or more payout complaints per 100 reviews.
  • Accounts lost to rule disputes4 or more rule-dispute reviews per 100 reviews.
  • Complaints are risingAt least 15% of the latest reviews are 1–2★, and that is double the share across the whole profile.
  • Less than a year oldUnder one year of payout history.

Pass rates

Always labeled

Few firms publish pass rates, and the ones you see on comparison sites rarely say where they came from. We label every figure:

  • Reported: published by the firm.
  • Third-party: from an independent source with a stated method.
  • Estimate: our estimate from the challenge rules.

Estimates compare a program's targets, loss limits, drawdown type and minimum days with programs whose pass rates have been disclosed (firms running standard two-step challenges have reported roughly 10% of attempts reaching a funded account). They indicate difficulty. They are not a promise.

How we analyze reviews

Bulk, not cherry-picked

For every firm we collect reviews from its main Trustpilot profile in bulk, in every language and the same way for every firm: the 200 latest reviews of any rating plus the 250 latest one- and two-star reviews, each with the firm's public reply. Each review page states its exact sample and dates. Where Trustpilot publishes 12-month transparency figures we use them for the monthly trend. We then:

  • measure sentiment and the average rating month by month, and whether it is improving or declining
  • classify every negative review, in its own language, by complaint theme: denied payouts, rule disputes, delays, support, execution, purchases and refunds, KYC
  • read the firm's reply next to each complaint. A reply can move a complaint out of "rule dispute" when it names a specific reason that isn't a trading rule, such as a new-customer offer bought twice, a chargeback or a restricted country. A reply that names a broken trading rule confirms the dispute. A reply never removes a review from the star counts
  • count how many recent reviews mention payouts, and how many of those are negative
  • flag review-health signals, such as the share of very short five-star reviews or Trustpilot warnings
  • check the classification by hand: every case a reply changed, plus a random sample from every firm

We paraphrase what reviewers say and never republish review text or reviewer names. Shares are always stated against the sample they come from.

Sources

Each review lists its sources: the firm's website, terms, FAQ and help center, Trustpilot, PropFirmMatch, Reddit threads and press coverage. Prices are standard list prices before discount codes. We refresh every firm regularly and after material events.

Independence

Money

Some links to firms may be affiliate links that pay us a commission if you buy. That never changes a grade, a score or what we report, and firms cannot pay for placement. Low-graded firms stay listed with the same detail as high-graded ones. Read the full disclosure.

Questions about the method

FAQ

Why letter grades instead of stars?

Stars on review platforms bunch up between 4 and 5 for nearly every prop firm, so they don't separate good firms from risky ones. A simple A to E grade built from payouts, rules and reputation spreads firms out and tells you at a glance how much risk you take.

Is a grade someone's opinion?

Every grade starts from the same formula and the same measured facts: Trustpilot reviews analysed in bulk, the firm's prices and its rules. When a firm gives us data we can verify, such as payout records or pass-rate data, our review team checks it and can adjust that firm's scores. The same applies to every firm.

Can a firm pay for a better grade?

No. Grades come from the method on this page, the evidence listed in each review and data firms provide that our review team has verified. Affiliate commissions, if any, never change a score, and firms cannot pay to remove information.

How often do grades change?

We refresh every firm regularly and immediately after material events such as rule changes, payout suspensions or ownership changes.

A firm says your data is wrong. What happens?

Send the correction and a source to hello@propfirmgrades.com. We verify it, update the review and note the change. We don't remove accurate information on request.