Head to head
Lucid Trading vs Take Profit Trader
Take Profit Trader grades higher overall, 6.6 to 6.5. Across 21 measurable rows, Lucid Trading comes out ahead on 6 and Take Profit Trader on 5.
Cheap, fast-paying futures evals, with a ban problem at payout that Lucid has not addressed
The best payout policy in futures, wrapped in funded-stage rules you must read twice
Key differences
In short
- Take Profit Trader carries more hidden-rule risk (5.3 vs 5.0), led by: drawdown switches from end-of-day to intraday in pro.
- Only Lucid Trading sells instant programs.
Lucid Trading vs Take Profit Trader, side by side
The better value in each row is marked
| Criterion | ||
|---|---|---|
| Grade | ||
| Overall score | B6.5 | B6.6 |
| Payouts | 7.0 | 7.0 |
| Transparency | 5.2 | 6.0 |
| Rules & trading conditions | 5.6 | 5.6 |
| Reputation | 6.5 | 7.2 |
| Platforms & execution | 8.5 | 8.2 |
| Support | 6.6 | 6.0 |
| Evidence | ||
| Trustpilot | 4.4 (6.4K) | 4.4 (11K) |
| Pass rate | 15%Estimate | 36.2%Reported |
| Hidden risk | 5.0 HighHidden risk 5.0 out of 10, High | 5.3 HighHidden risk 5.3 out of 10, High |
| Negative recent reviews | 3.5% | 8% |
| Offer | ||
| $100K challenge | — | — |
| Cheapest account | $79 | $150 |
| Max allocation | $750K | $750K |
| Max profit split | 90% | 90% |
| Payouts | On request once a cycle's goals are met: daily on… | Daily, on demand from day one of the PRO account (profit… |
| Programs | 1-step, instant | 1-step |
| Current offer | 30% OFF· VAULT | — |
| Company | ||
| Headquarters | Dover, Delaware, United States | Windermere, Florida, United States |
| Years in business | 1 | 5 |
| Trading | ||
| Platforms | NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Rithmic, Quantower | NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Rithmic, Quantower |
| Assets | Futures, Indices, Commodities, Energies, Metals, Forex | Futures, Indices, Energies, Metals, Commodities |
| EAs | Allowed | Not allowed |
| News trading | Restricted | Restricted |
| Weekend holding | Not allowed | Not allowed |
| Copy trading | Restricted | Restricted |
| Hedging | Not allowed | Not allowed |
Dover, Delaware, United StatesWhich should you choose?
By trading style
| You are… | Pick | |
|---|---|---|
| Beginners | Either | Lucid Trading: Cheap evaluations, EOD drawdown and clear dashboards help, but a 4% trailing max loss and the strict hedging rules punish mistakes. |
| Experienced traders | Take Profit Trader | Disciplined intraday traders get daily, uncapped withdrawals and a path to a live 90% split if they size moderately. |
| Swing traders | Either | Lucid Trading: Every sim account is flattened at 4:45 PM ET, so overnight and weekend holds are impossible until live. |
| Scalpers | Either | Lucid Trading: Scalping is allowed, but trades under 5 seconds that make up most of the profit get flagged. |
| EA & algo traders | Lucid Trading | Bots and copiers are allowed, yet copying across accounts has triggered hedging and cross-user flags in recent reviews. |
| News traders | Either | Lucid Trading: News is allowed on Pro, Flex and Direct, but it is a hard breach on LucidDaily and big news days break Pro and Direct consistency. |
Verdicts
Lucid Trading verdict
Cheap, fast-paying futures evals, with a ban problem at payout that Lucid has not addressed
Best for: Solo intraday futures traders on a budget who want cheap EOD-drawdown evaluations and fast, frequent small payouts.
Avoid if: You share a household or network with another trader, use copiers across many accounts, hold overnight, or need a firm that explains its enforcement decisions.
Take Profit Trader verdict
The best payout policy in futures, wrapped in funded-stage rules you must read twice
Best for: Disciplined intraday futures traders on one or a few manually traded accounts who want daily, uncapped payouts
Avoid if: You hold overnight, run bots or cross-account copiers, size up hard at the open, or cannot live with an intraday trailing drawdown
Lucid Trading vs Take Profit Trader FAQ
Questions traders ask
Is Lucid Trading better than Take Profit Trader?
On our grading Take Profit Trader scores higher overall (6.6 vs 6.5, grade B vs B). Lucid Trading still comes out ahead on support, platforms. The better choice depends on your style: compare the rules rows above before buying.
Which is cheaper, Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader?
The cheapest accounts start at $79 at Lucid Trading and $150 at Take Profit Trader. Prices depend on program and size, so compare the challenges tables.
Which pays out more reliably, Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader?
Lucid Trading has the stronger payout score (Lucid Trading 7.0 vs Take Profit Trader 7.0). Lucid Trading pays on request once a cycle's goals are met: daily on luciddaily, about every 3 days on lucidpro and every 5 qualifying days on lucidflex and luciddirect; Take Profit Trader pays daily, on demand from day one of the pro account (profit above the buffer only).
Which has fewer hidden rules, Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader?
Lucid Trading has the lower Hidden Risk score (Lucid Trading 5.0, high; Take Profit Trader 5.3, high). Each review lists the specific rules behind the score.
Is it easier to pass Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader?
Lucid Trading: 15% (estimate). Take Profit Trader: 36.2% (reported). Estimates are a guide to difficulty only; drawdown type and daily loss rules matter as much as the target.
Compare Lucid Trading or Take Profit Trader with another firm
More head-to-heads
- FTMO vs Take Profit Trader
- Take Profit Trader vs The5ers
- Take Profit Trader vs Top One Futures
- FundedNext vs Take Profit Trader
- Bulenox vs Take Profit Trader
- Lucid Trading vs Top One Futures
- FundedNext vs Lucid Trading
- Bulenox vs Lucid Trading
- IQ Capital vs Lucid Trading
- FXIFY vs Lucid Trading
- Funded Futures Family vs Lucid Trading